Why was this manhole cover made in India instead of the U.S.?
Here's a random point of discussion for the day... Take a look at the photo in this blog post. It's a manhole cover on 9th Street in New York City, near 1st Avenue.
[Coincidentally, it is located right near the New York office of the Alliance for American Manufacturing (AAM).]
Here's the question: Why wasn't this manhole cover made in the U.S.? Why was New York City taxpayer money used to buy a foreign manhole cover instead of an American-made one?
Let's hypothesize that the City of New York chose to purchase from India due to lower cost. Ie: The manhole covers imported from India were X percent cheaper for Y quantity.
QUESTION: Is there anything wrong with NYC going with the lower-cost option?
Well, actually, let's find out WHY the Indian version was cheaper. Why might India be able to underbid its U.S. counterparts?
In 2008, the U.S. Commerce Department reviewed whether steel from India is being subsidized. It confirmed that upwards of 20 different subsidy programs (at both the federal and state government levels of India) are being used to benefit India's steel exports, to the detriment of U.S. producers.
These subsidy programs were found to be "countervailable," which means they violate existing U.S. trade laws and give India's producers an unfair advantage.
The Office of the U.S. Trade Representative (USTR) also reported on India's unfair trade practices for its steel industry on page 248 of its 2009 National Trade Estimate (NTE).
Bottom line: The price of the Indian manhole cover was artificially lowered in order to undercut a comparable U.S. producer. Furthermore, the choice to import these manhole covers means that no U.S. jobs were supported with the tax dollars spent.
By contast, buying American-made components for infrastructure work supports American jobs and helps boost the U.S. economy.
Related recent Blogs
- A bad time to sideline trade talks • by mmcmullan • 12/04/2013
- Infrastructure investment means job creation • by TGarland • 12/04/2013
- China trade deficit on pace for new record, but will anyone notice? Alliance for American Manufacturing (AAM) Statement. • by scapozzola • 12/04/2013
- What to do with abandoned factories? Bring in the artists! • by LDonia • 12/03/2013
- Surprise, surprise? Americans still say job creation should be top priority • by mmcmullan • 12/03/2013
- Fmr. Transportaion Secretary Ray LaHood urges infrastructure investment • by TGarland • 12/02/2013
- The Computer Wore Heels: Check out "Top Secret Rosies" • by mmcmullan • 12/02/2013
- December 2, 2013: American-made holiday shopping • by LDonia • 12/02/2013
- The Veep heads to Asia, while Michigan Democrats and automakers press the "currency issue" in TPP talks • by TGarland • 11/27/2013
- G+ Hangout postponed! • by LDonia • 11/26/2013