NPR gets it wrong on the Oakland-Bay Bridge story
In a story today on NPR's Morning Edition reporter Richard Gonzales examined the long-running construction of the new San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge.
The Bay Bridge has been plagued by cost overruns due to flawed steel sections imported from China. Unfortunately, Gonzales focused on the "advantages" enjoyed by the Chinese company, Shanghai Zhenhua Heavy Industries, including "modern production facilities, ships to deliver the steel and, of course, low-cost labor."
Gonzalez misses some key points:
- Labor costs are actually a very small part of the cost of steel production. They have only a marginal impact on steel pricing;
- Shanghai Zhenhua is a state-owned enterprise that receives massive energy subsidies from the Chinese government. These subsidies are actionable under world trade law;
- Beijing’s continuing, illegal currency manipulation enables Chinese manufacturers to underbid U.S. manufacturers.
By contrast, U.S. steelmakers utilize the most modern, computerized facilities in the world. It’s stunning to suggest that Chinese firms would have more “modern production.”
Sadly, the cost overruns resulting from faulty Chinese steel could have been avoided by instead using reliable, American-made steel. As the National Steel Bridge Alliance (NSBA)has pointed out, U.S. firms did indeed stand ready to supply the steel for the bridge.
What’s really at stake are good-paying U.S. jobs, and the continuing viability of the U.S. steel industry. Gonzales has simply continued some of the inaccurate assumptions that proliferate in the media. If he has real concerns about jobs in America, we hope he'll work to set the record straight.
Related recent Blogs
- RADIO: AAM's Scott Paul on Leslie Marshall Radio Show, May 20, 2013 • by scapozzola • 05/21/2013
- May 21, 2013 Headlines: Tensions with North Korea, a stronger WTO, and more. • by LRaup • 05/21/2013
- Shoring up our security means addressing the China challenge • by mmcmullan • 05/20/2013
- Quote of the Day from Caterpillar's Doug Oberhelman • by LDonia • 05/20/2013
- May 20, 2013 Headlines: Manufacturing & social media, growth of the U.S. economy, and more. • by LRaup • 05/20/2013
- President Obama visits Baltimore factory to promote infrastructure investment as a means of revitalizing the middle class • by LDonia • 05/17/2013
- It's Fashion Friday, but NoCargo carries more than just American-made clothing! • by LDonia • 05/17/2013
- May 17, 2013 Headlines: Strengthening our national security, focusing on jobs, and more. • by LRaup • 05/17/2013
- Five reasons you should be concerned about the U.S. military's reliance on foreign manufacturers. • by LDonia • 05/16/2013
- Looking for a manufacturing job? Consider heading to one of these ten metro areas! • by mmcmullan • 05/16/2013