Bad policy sent America's manufacturing jobs to China; China throws in some U.S. pollution as a bonus

Posted by mmcmullan on 01/22/2014

We’ve sung the blues a lot over American manufacturing’s 15-year exodus. A lot of the jobs the U.S. lost were due to self-inflicted wounds. Bad fiscal policy prescriptions (a strong dollar) didn’t help. Nor have some questionable trade deals (that giant sucking sound). And neither did Washington’s all-in effort to grant the Chinese government Permanent Normalized Trade Relations (PNTR) in the year 2000. China got the threat of an annual shift in U.S. tariffs taken off the table and a subsequent influx of manufacturing jobs, while America got lots of marginally cheaper stuff on the shelves of big box stores.

Yessir, that is what's called a bum deal.

But that’s not all! A just-published study finds that, in addition to a retail revolution, we also get a lot of airborne pollutants. From a press release announcing the research:

Los Angeles experiences at least one extra day a year of smog that exceeds federal ozone limits because of nitrogen oxides and carbon monoxide emitted by Chinese factories making goods for export, the analysis found. On other days, as much as a quarter of the sulfate pollution on the U.S. West Coast is tied to Chinese exports. All the contaminants tracked in the study are key ingredients in unhealthy smog and soot.

Back in 2009, an Alliance for American Manufacturing (AAM) report unpacked the economic benefits the Chinese steel industry had thus far received from the nearly complete lack of environmental regulation administered by its own government. The absence of regulatory oversight for China’s heavy industry was really astounding:

Low standards combined with heavy industry investments to expand capacity, as well as poor regulation and enforcement, result in far more pollution from steel plants in China than in the United States. Although both the Chinese government and leading companies in the steel industry claim they want to address the industry’s environmental problems, the levels of pollution are still three to 20 times higher per ton of steel produced in China than in the United States, depending on the specific pollutant and industrial process analyzed.

In fact, in addition to the smog cover regularly gifted to Southern California, that AAM report found such pollution was the cause of thousands of premature deaths in China each year.

But hey: Cheap stuff, right?

You can read a write-up of the new study in the New York Times. Or you can read the whole scholarly thing online at the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, smartypants.

Image of China's Pearl River in Guangzhou by Flickr user Jaaron used following Creative Commons guidelines.

Related recent Blogs

@KeepitMadeinUSA on Twitter

  • Analysis from @YahooFinance: "There is a difference between growth in manufacturing and a renaissance." 1 hour 41 min ago
  • Wait, what? U.S. military coins are Made in... China? @JanMurphy has the details. 2 hours 12 min ago
  • A good sign? More laid-off workers are finding jobs in their fields. 2 hours 42 min ago
  • .@royhouseman from @steelworkers talked about what's next for #SOSJobs on @BloombergNews. Check it out: 3 hours 27 min ago
  • ICYMI: Our @ScottPaulAAM chatted w/ @EdShow about why it's so vital we level the playing field for U.S. tire makers. 3 hours 45 min ago
  • Obama admin placed tariffs on China-made tires, but expired. Hope tariffs are put back in place, but we also must be more proactive. #edshow 19 hours 12 min ago
  • Countries like China subsidize tires they produce. Tariffs level the playing field for U.S. manufacturers & workers, says @ScottPaulAAM. 19 hours 14 min ago
  • "Tariffs help to level the playing field -- nothing more and nothing less." -@ScottPaulAAM 19 hours 15 min ago
  • On @EdShow NOW: Unfair trade practices mean tire manufacturing workers are struggling to keep their jobs... 19 hours 17 min ago
  • Our @ScottPaulAAM will be on the @EdShow in the next segment... tune in NOW! 19 hours 27 min ago